Head to head
Citi Custom Cash vs Blue Cash Everyday
Updated June 2026 · Decided by net annual value (rewards minus the effective fee), not by who pays us.
Citi Custom Cash
No annual fee
Blue Cash Everyday
No annual fee
The verdict
Citi Custom Cash wins 6 of 6 sample spending profiles — by about $113/yr on average where it leads. Blue Cash Everyday doesn't win a single one.
Below: net annual value for each card across six representative spending profiles. Your real numbers will differ — run them here.
Who wins, by how you spend
Net annual value (after the effective fee). The higher number wins each row.
Everyday balanced
A typical mix — some groceries and dining, a little travel, and a big catch-all bucket.
Citi Custom Cash
$521/yr
Blue Cash Everyday
$419/yr
Grocery-heavy family
A household cooking mostly at home — supermarkets are the top line.
Citi Custom Cash
$522/yr
Blue Cash Everyday
$432/yr
Dining-out foodie
Restaurants and delivery dominate the month.
Citi Custom Cash
$457/yr
Blue Cash Everyday
$289/yr
Frequent traveler
Flights, hotels, and rideshare are the biggest category.
Citi Custom Cash
$499/yr
Blue Cash Everyday
$334/yr
Heavy commuter
A long daily drive — gas is the standout category.
Citi Custom Cash
$412/yr
Blue Cash Everyday
$352/yr
Big spender
High spend across every category.
Citi Custom Cash
$820/yr
Blue Cash Everyday
$730/yr
The fine print, side by side
These are six sample profiles. Yours is one.
Enter your actual monthly spending and we'll rank both of these — and every other card — by what they'd net you.
Run your numbersAdvertising disclosure: we may earn a commission if you apply through this link. This does not affect your ranking. Full disclosure
Figures are estimates from our net-value model on fixed sample profiles, using the point valuations on our methodology page. Rates and fees change — verify on the issuer's site before applying.